Overstock
Maitake vs. Shiitake: A Health Benefit Comparison
Learn all about maitake and shiitake mushrooms, their differences and benefits, and how to incorporate them into your daily wellness with Sunmed.
Functional mushrooms have found their way into everything from coffee alternatives to wellness routines.
Mushrooms like maitake and shiitake have long been recognized for their naturally occurring compounds that may support overall well-being.* Both are widely used in culinary traditions and are now being studied for their adaptogenic and immune-supporting properties.
Understanding the differences between maitake and shiitake mushrooms is a great place to start if you're looking to support immune function, improve mental clarity, or explore plant-based wellness.
What are maitake and shiitake mushrooms?
Maitake, also known as "hen of the woods," is a soft, feathered mushroom native to Japan and parts of North America. It typically grows in clusters at the base of hardwood trees and has been used in traditional Eastern wellness practices for generations.
Shiitake mushrooms are also native to East Asia and are more familiar to many people because of their wide culinary use. With a richer umami flavor and firm texture, they are commonly found in stir-fries, soups, and broths. Beyond their flavor, shiitake mushrooms have also been used in wellness traditions for their unique bioactive compounds.*
Both mushrooms contain a range of naturally occurring nutrients and compounds, including beta-glucans, ergothioneine, and other antioxidants, that can play a role in supporting wellness.*
Maitake vs. shiitake: What are their nutritional differences?
While both mushrooms are low in calories and fat, they pack a significant nutritional punch. Maitake and shiitake each offer fiber, B vitamins, and minerals like selenium, potassium, and copper, which are essential for cellular function and general health.*
Maitake is particularly rich in vitamin D (when exposed to sunlight or UV light), along with niacin and riboflavin. Its beta-glucan content is considered high among functional mushrooms, which may help support immune health and a balanced stress response.*
Shiitake mushrooms contain lentinan, a polysaccharide that has been studied for its ability to help support a healthy immune system.* They also contain ergothioneine, a naturally occurring amino acid with antioxidant properties that may help combat oxidative stress.*
These mushrooms aren't just about individual nutrients. Their unique combinations of vitamins, minerals, and functional compounds offer full-spectrum support for those looking to complement their wellness routines naturally.*
What are the wellness benefits of maitake mushrooms?
Maitake mushrooms are known for their adaptogenic qualities. In other words, they may help the body adapt to occasional stress and promote internal balance.*
Their rich content of beta-glucans is particularly noteworthy. These natural polysaccharides are believed to play a role in supporting the immune system's normal functioning.*
The potential benefits of maitake mushrooms include:
- Supporting immune function by helping modulate the body's natural defenses*
- Promoting energy and vitality through their adaptogenic effects*
- Supporting metabolic wellness and healthy glucose balance, according to early research*
- Contributing to emotional wellness and mood regulation by helping the body manage stressors*
Research is still growing in this area, but maitake continues to gain interest among wellness communities for its comprehensive profile of naturally supportive compounds.*
What are the wellness benefits of shiitake mushrooms?
Shiitake mushrooms are known for their antioxidant and immune-supportive properties. Their lentinan content is often studied for its potential to help support a healthy immune response, while their naturally occurring ergothioneine offers additional support for oxidative balance.*
Other potential wellness benefits of shiitake include:
- Supporting skin wellness, due to its content of copper and amino acids that contribute to collagen formation*
- Helping promote gut balance with polysaccharides that may nourish the microbiome*
- Offering cognitive support through its antioxidant properties that may protect neural cells from oxidative stress*
- Providing cardiovascular support by helping maintain already healthy cholesterol levels, as observed in early studies*
Like maitake, shiitake continues to be explored in clinical and wellness settings alike. Its versatile profile makes it a valuable option for those looking to support overall health through functional foods.*
What are the key differences between maitake and shiitake?
While both mushrooms offer meaningful support, they have different strengths. Maitake tends to lean more adaptogenic, offering potential support for energy, mood, and metabolic balance.* Shiitake is often highlighted for its antioxidant and immune-supporting profile and its role in gut wellness.*
From a culinary perspective, shiitake mushrooms have a firmer texture and a stronger umami flavor, making them a favorite in savory dishes.
Maitake mushrooms are more delicate, with a feathery texture and a nutty, earthy taste. They can be cooked together, but their individual strengths can also shine in different recipes and formats.
Another point of difference is cultivation. Shiitake is usually grown on logs or sawdust blocks, while maitake often grows at the base of oak or maple trees.
How to incorporate maitake or shiitake into your routine
Adding functional mushrooms can elevate your sense of wellness. Both maitake and shiitake can be enjoyed in everyday meals, brewed into teas, or taken as part of a wellness supplement.
Cooking with fresh or dried mushrooms is a great starting point. Maitake sautés beautifully with garlic and olive oil or adds depth to broth-based dishes. Shiitake is especially good in stir-fries, noodle bowls, and even roasted as a crispy snack.
When selecting mushrooms, opt for organic and fruiting body-based sources to benefit most from their natural compounds.
For those seeking a more convenient everyday option, Sunmed’s All-in-One Mushroom Gummies offer a daily serving of ten functional mushroom extracts, including both maitake and shiitake. Formulated with fruiting body extracts, these wild raspberry flavored support gummies deliver adaptogenic and nootropic support for mood, memory, focus, immune function, stress response, and digestion.* It’s an easy way to add mushroom-powered wellness to your routine without the need for prep or cooking.
Which mushroom is right for you?
Choosing between maitake and shiitake comes down to your personal wellness goals. If you're looking to support your body’s natural stress response or energy levels, maitake might be a great addition to your routine.*
If you're more interested in supporting your skin, immune health, or gut function, shiitake could be a better fit.
But it doesn't have to be either-or. That’s the beauty of a well-rounded functional mushroom blend. Our Mushroom Gummies combine the power of maitake, shiitake, lion’s mane, reishi, and six other mushroom fruiting body extracts to deliver comprehensive support.*
Whether you're cooking up a savory dish or incorporating functional mushrooms into your supplement stack, maitake and shiitake both offer plant-based support to help you feel your best.
The bottom line
At Sunmed, our commitment to natural wellness is rooted in transparency, education, and clean ingredients.
We create premium, third-party tested, hemp-derived products designed to support your wellness journey, backed by science and powered by nature. From our functional mushroom blends to our full spectrum CBD collections, every formula is crafted with intention, using only the highest-quality ingredients.
*This statement has not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Sources: