Overstock
CBD vs. melatonin for sleep: A detailed comparison
CBD and melatonin are commonly used for sleep, but which one works best? Take a deep dive into sleep support with this guide.
Key Takeaways:
- Melatonin is best for short-term sleep schedule disruptions, like jet lag.
- Long-term melatonin use may disrupt your natural sleep hormone balance, while CBD does not.
- CBD may help address multiple causes of poor sleep, including stress, tension, and discomfort.
Sleep is one of those things you don’t truly appreciate until it starts slipping through your fingers. About a third of all people report that they're dissatisfied with their sleep habits, and many people find themselves reaching for help to get some rest.
Two popular choices are CBD (cannabidiol) and melatonin, but they work in very different ways. While melatonin has long been marketed as a natural sleep solution, its actual effectiveness may not live up to the hype. CBD offers a more holistic approach to sleep by supporting your body’s rhythms without attempting to change how they work.
Let’s compare them and consider what to consider when deciding between them.
How melatonin works
Melatonin is a hormone your body naturally produces in response to darkness. Its main job is to help regulate your circadian rhythm, which is the medical term for your internal 24-hour clock. When the sun goes down, melatonin levels rise, signaling to your body that it’s time to wind down.
The supplement version is a synthetic copy of the hormone, available as supplement pills, gummies, or drops. The idea is that by giving your body more melatonin, you’ll fall asleep faster. However, there’s a catch — melatonin is a timing signal, not a sedative.
If your sleep troubles stem from stress, discomfort, irregular schedules, or restless thoughts, simply flooding your system with extra melatonin might not do much.
Concerns about melatonin supplements
Melatonin is hit or miss in a lot of situations. Many people find that melatonin doesn't help them as effectively as they'd hoped.
Here's why:
- Short-term use only : Studies suggest melatonin may help in specific short term situations, like adjusting to jet lag or shifting sleep schedules It’s not meant for nightly long-term use.
- Using too much melatonin: Too much melatonin can cause grogginess, headaches, dizziness, or even disrupt your natural hormone balance.
- Variable results: People respond differently to melatonin. Some feel drowsy quickly, while others feel nothing at all. Some people even report that melatonin gives them weird dreams.
- Possible lingering effects: High doses can leave you feeling sluggish and unfocused the following day.
The main issue is that melatonin doesn’t address the root causes of poor sleep. It's only measurably effective for schedule dysregulation.
How does CBD work for sleep?
CBD (cannabidiol) is a non-intoxicating compound that naturally occurs in hemp plants. Unlike melatonin, it doesn’t send your body a specific sleep signal.
Instead, CBD interacts with your body’s endocannabinoid system (ECS), which is a vast network of receptors that helps regulate balance in mood, stress response, discomfort, and relaxation.
CBD for sleep support
CBD may offer a broader range of bedtime support by addressing your need for relaxation holistically.
- Targets stress and tension: Many sleep problems are rooted in feelings of discomfort or unease. CBD may help promote a sense of calm, making it easier to fall asleep naturally.*
- Addresses multiple causes: Whether your sleep troubles stem from an overactive mind, minor discomfort, or irregular patterns, CBD works on a broader scale by interacting with your entire endocannabinoid system.*
Unlike melatonin, CBD isn’t tied to a single mechanism. It helps your body find balance, so your sleep cycle can work the way it’s meant to.
Comparing CBD vs. melatonin
Let’s break down the similarities and differences between CBD and melatonin. Comparing and contrasting can help you determine which option is best for your sleep situation.
|
Feature |
CBD |
Melatonin |
|
How it works |
Supports balance in the nervous system and stress response through the ECS |
Signals your body that it’s nighttime, helping reset circadian rhythm |
|
Best for |
Tension-related sleep issues, occasional discomfort, improving sleep quality |
Short-term circadian disruptions (jet lag, changing work shifts) |
|
Habit forming |
No |
Low risk, but long-term use may disrupt natural melatonin production |
|
Side effects |
Generally mild (dry mouth, digestive changes at high doses) |
Grogginess, headaches, dizziness, vivid dreams |
|
Flexibility |
Can be used nightly |
Can be used occasionally |
If you’re temporarily out of sync, melatonin can work. If you’re seeking long-term support, it’s more likely that CBD will be the most effective option.
One of the biggest misconceptions about melatonin is that it works like a sleeping pill. In reality, its role is far more limited. Research shows that melatonin is most effective when your body’s natural clock is temporarily out of sync, like when traveling across time zones.
If you struggle with everyday stress, an overactive mind, or environmental factors (like noise or light), melatonin doesn’t do much to resolve those issues.
CBD offers a gentler, more adaptable approach to better sleep. Rather than forcing your body into a hormonal signal, CBD can work with your existing systems to promote overall balance throughout your body.
The bottom line
When comparing CBD and melatonin, the difference is clear. Melatonin is a short-term fix with a narrow focus, while CBD supports the broader ecosystem of your internal processes.
Melatonin may be useful for the occasional jet-lagged traveler or night shift worker adjusting their schedule, but it doesn’t resolve the deeper causes behind most sleep struggles.
At Sunmed, our CBD for sleep is crafted to help you sleep better naturally. We don’t like the side effects of melatonin, so we’ve opted out of including it in our formula. Instead, we combine CBD with sleep-supporting CBN, valerian root, and lavender for natural soothing support.
*This statement has not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
FAQs
Can I take CBD and melatonin together?
Some products combine them, but if you’re skeptical about melatonin for long-term use, you may prefer trying CBD alone first to see how your body responds.
How quickly does CBD work for sleep?
Many people notice a sense of calm within 30-60 minutes. CBD works best with consistent use. If you use your CBD every day as part of your wellness routine, you're more likely to notice a pronounced effect.
Is CBD safe to take every night?
Current research suggests CBD is well-tolerated for daily use. Always choose quality-tested products and start with a moderate serving size.
Will CBD make me feel groggy in the morning?
Unlike melatonin, CBD is less likely to cause drowsiness, especially when you find your ideal dosage.
Sources:
How Does Melatonin Work? | Cleveland Clinic
Cannabidiol in Anxiety and Sleep: A Large Case Series | PubMed
The Endocannabinoid System and its Modulation by Phytocannabinoids | PubMed